Pledge of Allegiance or blind obedience?

Late last week four students from Dilworth, Minnesota were suspended from school. Not for carrying firearms, dealing drugs, or fighting during school hours. These four rebels with a clue were suspended for {gasp!} not standing during the Pledge of Allegiance!

Late last week four students from Dilworth, Minnesota were suspended from school. Not for carrying firearms, dealing drugs, or fighting during school hours. These four rebels with a clue were suspended for {gasp!} not standing during the Pledge of Allegiance!

Now, I realize that Dilworth, Minnesota is a hotbed of political unrest, but can’t we all just settle down and not jump to the conclusion that these kids are future terrorists?

The principal, Colleen Houglum told the “Dilworth Four” that not standing during the pledge of allegiance was disrespectful to the troops fighting in Iraq. The student handbook states that “All students will stand” during the pledge but you are not required to recite it.

My question is why the principal is suspending perfectly good students for simply believing in their right of free expression?

The Pledge of Allegiance is a time-honored tradition of bleary-eyed youngsters pledging unquestioning patriotism to our government. And as most traditions go, this one needs to go permanently. We have been dealing with this issue since the 1970s, when it was ok to question one’s government, to today when questioning our government’s actions labels us boat rockers.

This is just another example of meaningless gestures put upon the American public to make us feel better and safer knowing that our government is above reproach.

How do you show your patriotism? Got the yellow magnetic bow that says “We support the Troops” for your Suburban? How about the American Flag on the front porch? Do you make sure your little tyke knows all the words to “Proud to be an American” by Lee Greenwood?

If so, congratulations: you are what our current government wants in a voter and a citizen – blind obedience.

As far as the Pledge of Allegiance is concerned, we need to get rid of it.

You can show your patriotism by being a well-informed voter. You can show love for your country by questioning your government. And if you are in the eighth grade in Dilworth, Minnesota, you can get the admiration of the entire U.S.A. by simply not standing up for the “pledge” but by sitting down.

Todd Nuttman is a resident of Kent and a new columnist for the Kent Reporter. Send your responses for Nuttman to: laura.pierce@reporternewspapers.com.

More in Opinion

Lawmakers look to reduce what they increased | The Petri Dish

Funny how things change around here in the turn of a calendar… Continue reading

Cities balancing budgets with fees | Brunell

State considering additional taxes

Message from new KCLS director

As the new director of the King County Library System, I am… Continue reading

Military leaders can transform education | Brunell

Do good military commanders make good education leaders? That is a question… Continue reading

Time to focus on school choice across America | Guest column

By Andrew R. Campanella/National School Choice Week Later this month, schools, home-school… Continue reading

China’s sword policy cutting deep into recycling | Brunell

Earlier this month, China launched its “national sword” policy which bans many… Continue reading

Ecosystem out of balance | Being Frank

Urging ways to improve our regional habitat

What’s the tab? | Shiers

The cost to renew your car tabs in our state remains excessively… Continue reading

For opponents of a carbon tax, an initiative threat looms

If legislators don’t act on the governor’s legislation, a plan could land on the November ballot.

Inslee: ‘It’s our state’s destiny … to fight climate change’

In his State-of-the-State address, the governor made the case for an ambitious carbon tax.

Eyman vows to rebound from setbacks | The Petri Dish

2017 was a stinky year for Tim Eyman. It ended with a… Continue reading

Reflecting on the old and ringing in the New Year | KCLS

What a busy and eventful year this has been. As I write… Continue reading