Robert Toomey, CFA/CFP, is Vice President of Research for S. R. Schill & Associates on Mercer Island.

Robert Toomey, CFA/CFP, is Vice President of Research for S. R. Schill & Associates on Mercer Island.

Is cryptocurrency really an investment? | Guest column

Undoubtedly you have heard about the new form of money known as digital or “crypto” currencies.

It is a fascinating new development in the financial world and it has caught a huge amount of attention on Wall Street as people try to capitalize on it. To define it, a “crypto” or digital currency (DC), is a form of “money” represented by digital data, or a data file, that can be used for the payment of goods and services online. A couple of the more popular cryptos include Bitcoin and Ethereum, but there are in the neighborhood of 4,500 private cryptocurrencies now identified.

There are a lot of big time players on Wall Street looking to capitalize on the current digital currency craze. They do this in several ways, for example “mining” and acquiring the DCs (or “tokens”); trading in the stocks of companies that purport to mine, use, or own DCs; or trading DC futures. We’ve gotten numerous questions from clients about DCs and “investing” in them. This begs the question: are DCs such as bitcoin truly an investment?

To answer this, let’s first define an “investment.” In my view, an investment involves the process of analyzing and placing money into a vehicle or instrument that one believes has a high probability of providing gain, or a positive return on capital (ROC), based on a definable and predictable source of return such as income (i.e. rent or dividends) or price appreciation based on future earnings. In other words, to be an “investment,” there needs to be a “fundamental” basis for the placement of funds. The “instrument” could be things that are expected to generate a positive ROC such as a bank CD, a high quality stock or bond, real estate, a mutual fund, etc.

So let’s turn to cryptocurrency. Is it an “investment?”

Based on the above definition of an investment, we think not. Crypto does not have definable “cash flow” such as earnings or dividends. Its price is extremely volatile making it a poor store of value. The key to trading or owning crypto is its perceived scarcity value. Many players in the crypto space believe a DC such as bitcoin will only increase in value due to their limited quantity (21 million produced) and increasing number and value of transactions using DCs. While this may be the case, it needs to be understood that the DC is only the medium for transactions; it is not providing the characteristics of an investment.

Trading in crypto is then really more a form of speculation, in my view, which is purely guessing on the future price of something based on non-fundamental factors, such as emotion or fear of missing out. As we do for all our clients’ investments, we believe the best approach for achieving positive ROC is accomplished through investing in diversified holdings of quality stocks and bonds that offer a rational basis for ownership based on sound financial fundamentals.

Robert Toomey, CFA/CFP, is Vice President of Research for S. R. Schill & Associates on Mercer Island.


Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing editor@kentreporter.com.

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website https://www.kentreporter.com/submit-letter/. Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) Please keep letters to 300 words or less.

More in Business

t
Rite Aid expands Des Moines distribution center despite store closures

Company closing distribution center in Oregon; shifting operations to Washington

Anne Smith of Retro Emporium in Kent with an alien invader from "Mars Attacks!". Photo by Bailey Jo Josie/Sound Publishing.
Ack ack ack! Retro Emporium attacks with four Best of Kent awards

Since opening in 2019, Retro Emporium in Kent has been a favorite… Continue reading

Reber Ranch has been open in Kent since 1984. Photo by Bailey Jo Josie/Sound Publishing.
Reber Ranch gets the blue ribbon

A pet store, feed store, grooming salon and veterinary office all rolled… Continue reading

Photo courtesy of Big Chicken:
The first Shaquille O’Neal’s Big Chicken to open in Washington state is at the Climate Pledge Arena in Seattle, with the new Renton location being the second.
Shaq’s Big Chicken partners with Kent’s Blue Origin for space postcards

Big Chicken postcards will be placed aboard an upcoming Blue Origin space mission

Courtesy Image, Better Business Bureau
Better Business Bureau issues warning about Kent construction company

DJE Concrete & Construction receives F rating from agency after failing to complete jobs

t
AWB manufacturing week tour makes stops in Kent, Auburn

Tour highlights Motors and Controls; Boeing Additive Manufacturing plant

Photos by Bailey Jo Josie/Sound Publishing
June Paik (left) and her employees at Master Hair Care can work with clients for hours to find the perfect wig or hair piece.
Master Hair Care offers quality wigs, warm service for cancer patients

Located in Federal Way, this woman-owned small business is one of the most recommended in the area for people experiencing hair loss.

t
FAA closes Kent-based Blue Origin flight mishap investigation

Agency requires company to implement 21 corrective actions before next launch

t
Simpson Strong-Tie opens new Kent distribution center

Company makes structural connectors for construction industry; facility on former Boeing property

t
Kent salon owner bounces back from shop’s building fire

Wilder and Free Beauty Company sustains damage in Sept. 2 fire; seeks temporary location

t
Seattle Children’s to close downtown Kent thrift store

Kent Bargain Boutique opened 28 years ago

Dante is from the Netherlands and currently lives at Serenity Equine. He is a therapy horse who works with veterans from the Odyssey Project for Wounded Warriors. (Photos by Bailey Jo Josie/Sound Publishing)
King County horse rescue organization falls on hard times

The Serenity Equine Rescue and Rehabilitation in Maple Valley is one of the top local horse rescues, but it’s struggling amid the aftermath of the pandemic and the increasing cost of hay. The rescue will hold a fundraising benefit Sept. 9.