Lawsuit challenges county initiative to ban safe injection sites

  • Tuesday, August 22, 2017 12:01pm
  • News

A new lawsuit may eventually decide the fate of safe drug sites in King County, adding yet another twist to an ongoing public policy drama that has been unfolding across the county.

First, there was an opioid crisis, beginning in the early 2000s and continuing today. Then, last year, at the behest of a public health task force, local leaders pledged to create two pilot safe drug sites as a harm-reduction measure. Then, this year, opponents collected enough signatures to put an initiative on the ballot to ban safe drug sites throughout the county.

Then, on Monday, harm reduction advocates under the group name Protect Public Health went to court to block that initiative from ever appearing on a ballot. The King County Council voted Monday to put the measure on the February ballot.

“The proposed I-27, in its entirety, is invalid because it is beyond the scope of the local initiative power, and therefore null and void,” summarizes the lawsuit in its request for relief. Authored by attorneys Knoll Lowney and Claire Tonry, the suit’s argument goes like this:

1. Local ballot initiatives can’t take away authority delegated to city officials by the state Legislature. “An initiative is beyond the scope of the initiative power if the initiative involves powers granted by the Legislature to the governing body of a city, rather than the city itself,” reads one quotation from the judgment in Mukilteo Citizens for Simple Gov’t v. City of Mukilteo. And another from City of Sequim v. Malkasian: “Stated another way, the people cannot deprive the city legislative authority of the power to do what the constitution and/or a state statute specifically permit it to do.”

2. State law delegates health decisions to local health officials—specifically, the Local Health Officer and the Board of Health.

3. Therefore, local ballot initiatives cannot override public health decisions made by local health authorities, including how to address the opioid crisis.

“The public health of the entire state would be jeopardized if a local initiative or referenda could derail local action to stem an epidemic,” reads the suit, “which is precisely what I-27 seeks to do.”

“I-27 would set a dangerous precedent for public health. Supervised Consumption Spaces are an essential tool in fighting the opiate epidemic,” Dr. Bob Wood, Director of the HIV/AIDS Program at Public Health-Seattle & King County from 1986 to 2010 and member of Protect Public Health, said in a statement. “If I-27 succeeds, other public health policies could be at risk, including vaccination requirements, needle exchange programs, or even efforts to combat sexually transmitted diseases.”

I-27 campaign manager Keith Schipper responded to the lawsuit.

“This is just another attempt by the powers-that-be to disenfranchise the KC voters that want to have their say on this radical policy proposal,” he said.

The Kent City Council voted 6-1 on Aug. 15 to approve a six-month ban on locating a safe injection site in the city.

Contributed by Casey Jaywork. Reach Casey at cjaywork@seattleweekly.com

A version of this story first appeared in the Seattle Weekly, part of the Sound Publishing chain that owns the Kent Reporter.

More in News

Sound Transit Board approves Kent parking garage site for train commuters

The Sound Transit Board approved on Thursday a preferred site for a… Continue reading

Former Kent-Meridian High School employee charged with raping student

A former office staff worker at Kent-Meridian High School was arrested Wednesday… Continue reading

Kent firefighters attack house fire in North Park | Update

A fire in a bedroom quickly spread at a home in the… Continue reading

Green River College’s Prime Time Program has successful fall kickoff

Green River College’s Prime Time Program kicked off its year with an… Continue reading

Constantine directs Public Health to oversee King County juvenile detention reorganization

As part of King County’s commitment to reduce traumatization of youth in… Continue reading

Kent moves closer to permanent ban against safe injection sites

Kent city officials took another step toward a permanent ban against safe… Continue reading

Kent city leaders approve property tax break for apartment developers

A Kent City Council committee approved multifamily property tax exemptions for two… Continue reading

Kent School District’s Vosper named Outstanding Teacher Librarian of the Year

Teacher-librarian Mary (Mimi) Vosper of Grass Lake Elementary School is the Washington… Continue reading

Most Read