Screenshot from a video posted by the Auburn Police Department shows the suspect in the attempted kidnapping of an Auburn barista.

Screenshot from a video posted by the Auburn Police Department shows the suspect in the attempted kidnapping of an Auburn barista.

Auburn man faces charge of attempted kidnapping of barista

King County prosecutors charge man in Jan. 16 incident at drive-thru window

The King County Prosecuting Attorneys’ Office on Jan. 19 formally charged an Auburn man with second-degree attempted kidnapping, three days after he allegedly tried to yank a woman through the drive-thru window at Beankini Espresso in north Auburn where she was working early on Monday morning, Jan. 16.

Auburn Police arrested Matthew William Darnell, 38, at his home in the 10000 block of Southeast 287th Street on Jan. 17.

Darnell is scheduled to be arraigned Jan. 26 at the Maleng Regional Justice Center in Kent. He remained Jan. 24 in the King County Correctional Facility in Seattle with bail set at $500,000, according to jail records.

Deputy Prosecuting Attorney Rhyan C. Anderson defined Darnell’s actions to court as “a deliberate and carefully-planned abduction attempt,” calculated to take place when it was still dark outside, and at a time where there were unlikely to be any other customers and very little pedestrian and vehicle traffic in the area.

Anderson noted the contrast between Darnell, who is 6 feet 5 inches tall and weighs 300 plus pounds. and his would-be-victim, who is 31 years old, 5 feet 2 inches tall and weighs about 110 pounds.

“He carefully chose a petite young woman who was working alone,” Anderson said, “wearing very little clothing, and with no means to protect herself. Further, the defendant was armed with a zip tie as a means of restraining his victim – a victim who was significantly smaller and 200 lbs less than the defendant…”

According to the APD’s Certification of Determination of Probable Cause, here is what happened.

At 5:06 a.m., a barista called 911 to report that a man had just tried to abduct her from her coffee stand at 2102 Auburn Way N., then drove away in a dark-colored truck.

According to the police narrative, the coffee stand’s external surveillance video shows a man extending his left hand out of the driver’s side window to hand the barista cash. As he does so, the video captures the image of a tattoo that extends along his entire forearm and appears to read “Chevrolet.”

According to the police narrative, when the barista puts her right hand out of the window to hand the man his change, he suddenly seizes her right wrist.

“[He] pulls her “violently towards him,” the police narrative says. “His body is now twisted as he extends [it] out of the open driver- door window. His right hand is then seen reaching out while holding what appears to be a closed, looped, black-colored ziptie,” with an opening about 10-12 inches in diameter.

“The suspect lurches out and appears to attempt to place the looped ziptie around the head of the victim as if to lasso her,” the narrative continues. “It just misses her head as she reacts and starts to pull back. [He loses] his grip on her right hand, allowing [her] to fall back into the stand. Once back, she quickly closes the window and moves out toward the cash register.”

Following the incident, the APD released information to the media, including the video and the image of the tattoo. And the public responded. Soon, the APD began receiving numerous tips about a possible suspect, with Matthew Darnell being the name most frequently mentioned.

According to the APD narrative, when police checked Darnell’s license, his picture appeared to resemble the barista’s description of the suspect’s face, and his state vehicle registration showed that he owned a 2019 Chevrolet Silverado truck, which, according to the narrative, had last been seen driving 1northbound on 104th Avenue Southeast about a mile north of the coffee stand.

On Jan. 17, detectives went to Darnell’s address and met him in his driveway. After officers read him his rights, according to the narrative, Darnell informed them he wanted to turn himself in. According to the narrative, Darnell’s face and hair and the tattoo on his left arm appeared to the officers to be an exact match to the suspect’s.

According to the narrative, Darnell then provided police voluntary consent to search his Chevrolet truck, which was in his driveway. When police searched the truck, according to the narrative, they found a black-colored ziptie about 10 inches in diameter under the front passenger seat, which appeared to match the size and width of the one seen on the video.Police also found an additional bundle of zip ties in Darnell’s bedroom.

According to court records, Auburn Police also obtained a search warrant for a forensic download of Darnell’s cell phone. At the time of this writing, however, that download had not yet been completed.

As Anderson told the court, “It still remains unknown what the defendant had planned to do with this young woman had he successfully zip-tied her and pulled her into his vehicle. However, the fact that he forcibly attempted to abduct a complete stranger warrants extreme alarm for the safety of the community.”

While Darnell has no known criminal history, Anderson noted, the premeditated nature of his “frightening offense” demonstrates the risk he poses to the community and to the victim.

If Darnell is able to post the $500,000 bail, Anderson said, he asked that the Court would require him to be on Electronic Home Detention with GPS monitoring. Anderson also asked the court to enter an order prohibiting Darnell from contacting the victim and the Beankini Espresso stand.

Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) Please keep letters to 300 words or less.

More in Northwest

Nicholas gets nearly 46 years for Federal Way murder of Sarah Yarborough

‘There will be accountability, no matter how many years it takes,’ judge said in court

A memorial at Stars Bar & Grill includes photos, cards, flowers and trinkets set in reverence of Jessyca Hohn and Katie Duhnke, who were killed just outside the bar May 21. Alex Bruell / The Mirror
Federal Way bar fatal shootings suspect identified; bartenders honored

Stars Bar & Grill customers celebrate lives of Jessyca Hohn and Katie Duhnke

Auburn Police arrest 2 juveniles in Oregon for fatal shooting

Pair caught day after May 30 shooting in Auburn

Court denies use of tattoos, prior cases as evidence in Auburn cop’s trial

Jeffrey Nelson is the first officer in state to face a murder charge since the passage of I-940.

File Photo
Renton first responders ‘endangered’ at illegal street race in Kent

Both the fire chief and the firefighters union issued statements regarding the May 21 incident.

Decatur High School senior and “American Idol” contestant Iam Tongi sits at home on March 1. His father Rodney spent a bonus from his job as an electrician to buy Iam’s guitar. Alex Bruell / The Mirror
It’s Iam: Federal Way student wins ‘American Idol’

The city of Federal Way is planning a celebration to honor the Decatur High student’s victory

King County Crime Dive podcast.
‘One-person crime wave’ sentenced for ghost gun and fentanyl | King County Crime Dive podcast

Also in this episode, a 17-year-old boy is injured while “surfing” on a vehicle.

Heavy traffic northbound on 1-5 in Everett, Washington on August 31, 2022. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Go early or late to beat Memorial Day weekend traffic

AAA projects busy airports, ferries and roads over the holiday weekend this year, though still below pre-pandemic counts.

Flowers and candles are left by the door of the Stars Bar & Grill in Federal Way, where two employees were shot and killed early Sunday morning, May 21. A third man was shot and taken to a hospital. ALEX BRUELL, Sound Publishing
2 employees killed, 1 customer injured at Federal Way bar shooting

Police looking for suspect in May 21 shooting at Stars Bar & Grill at 31216 Pacific Highway S.

Police lights (File photo)
Police investigating death of teenager in Renton

The 17-year-old was found with multiple gunshot wounds on May 6.

State Patrol uses aircraft to make traffic arrests in South King County

Crackdown on illegal street racing and vehicles fleeing from traffic stops

King County Crime Dive podcast.
Local member of Proud Boys is convicted | Podcast

A Washington, D.C., jury convicted an Auburn man and three other Proud Boys members of a plot to attack the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021.